3. La Traviata. Giuseppe Verdi (1813–1901) hit his stride with a trio of operas in mid-career: Rigoletto (1851), Il trovatore (The Troubadour, 1853), and La traviata (The Fallen Woman, also 1853). Unlike any of his other subjects, this last does not have an historical setting, but was absolutely up to the moment. Verdi’s librettist, Francesco Maria Piave, based his text upon the latest hit of the Paris season, La dame aux camélias (1852), the play that Alexandre Dumas fils based upon his 1848 novel of the same title.

The "Lady of the Camellias" was based on a real woman, Dumas’ own lover, Marie Duplessis, a courtesan who ran a celebrated salon but died of consumption (probably TB) at only 23. This would have been a well-known item of Parisian gossip. The management at Venice’s La Fenice opera, however, were taking no chances. Avoiding any hint of contemporary scandal, they insisted that the action be pushed back to the 17th century. It is not the décor, however, that makes the opera real, but the psychological insight into the characters, and this shows Verdi at his very best.

So La traviata was a contemporary opera forced into a period setting. But opera companies know that period spectacle tends to sell better than psychological realism, so the trade-off between grandeur of style and acuity of insight continues to this day. After watching substantial scenes from the first and last acts of the opera in a sensitive traditional production, we shall see how other directors have handled this dilemma.

 
The script, videos, and images will be posted immediately after class.

 
There are several productions of La traviata available on YouTube, but they come and go without warning. One good one that has been up for a long time, and so is likely to stay, is the 2006 San Fancisco production below, directed by Marta Domingo and starring Renée Fleming; it is not the sharpest video, but it is a strong traditional production and it is the only one that has titles. The London performance we watched in class and the 2005 Willy Decker production from Salzburg are also available complete, the one with Chinese titles, the other without any; these may not last. I have done the best I can with the others. rb.

COMPLETE PRODUCTIONS
  Domingo, San Francisco 2006   Full opera (with titles)
  Eyre, London 2019   Full opera (Chinese titles)
  Decker, Salzburg 2005   Full opera (no titles)
 
OTHER PRODUCTIONS
  Zeffirelli film, 1983   Excerpt from Act I (the main party scene)
  Mayer, Met 2019   Drinking song
  Livermore, Florence 2022   Trailer

• Return to top        • Return to index