8. Manon. The Prodigal Returns. A scene I look back on with especial fondness from my career as a stage director was no great aria or massive ensemble, but a scrap of conversation sung to nothing music to the strains of an offstage orchestra, the kind of thing nobody would bother to include in a disc of excerpts from the show. It comes in the third act of Massenet's Manon, and is simply the heroine casually enquiring of the Count des Grieux what has become of his son, her former lover. I know nothing quite like it in any other opera, so I immediately thought of it when choosing an extended scene for today's class: in this case, almost the entire third act, which strings together a great variety of different textures to create a dramatic roller-coaster beginning with a show-stopper aria and ending with one of the most sensuous (and perverse) duets in opera, as Manon seduces the former lover in the very church where he is about to take the vows of priesthood (illustration above).

I am not sure how much will come across out of context, but if you want an advance glance of the scene in question, there is a video of it here, with English titles; I will explain more in the class itself. There is a brief synopsis of the opera on the Handout. But again I have another terminally cute but winsomely hyper woman (this time American) telling the story at this link. rb. 
 

 
VIDEO LINKS

Both productions I showed in class are available complete on YouTube (yay!). The 2001 Paris version with Renée Fleming has English titles; the 2007 Netrebko/Villazón video does not. There is also a slightly blurry one from the Met in 2012 with Netrebko and Pyotr Beczala. I have cued all three to the major sections watched in class, whether we saw them in that version or not. Scenes that we did see are *asterisked.

There is a lot more out there. I have chosen a few clips that especially appealed to me, and divided them into two sections: other versions of scenes we saw, and scenes from elsewhere in the opera. I would especially draw your attention to the scene between Manon and the Count in the Met production, because I made a lot of this passage and it is rare that we get it singled out as a stand-alone excerpt. In both sections, I would recommend the Paris 2020 production, which is especially clear and stars Benjamin Bernheim, who is arguably the best French tenor currently out there. The final item is a trailer of a production in Switzerland, whose director gives a very intelligent explanation of what may seem an unusually radical concept. rb.

COMPLETE PRODUCTIONS
  Paris 2001   * Complete opera (Fleming/Alvarez, with titles)
* — first meeting
* — Manon's entrance, Act III
* — Saint Sulpice scene, Act III
  Berlin 2007   * Complete opera (Netrebko/Villazón)
* — first meeting
* — Manon's entrance, Act III
* — Saint Sulpice scene, Act III
  Met 2011   * Complete opera (Netrebko/Beczala)
* — first meeting
* — Manon's entrance, Act III
* — Saint Sulpice scene, Act III
OTHER VERSIONS OF SCENES WATCHED IN CLASS
  Act I meeting   * Met 2019 (Oropesa/Fabiano)
  Act III Gavotte   * Met 2011 (Anna Netrebko)
* Met 2019 (Lisette Oropesa)
* Paris 2020 (Pretty Yende)
  Act III, Manon and the Count   * Met 2011 (Netrebko with Kwangchul Youn)
  Act III, Saint Sulpice scene   * Vienna 2007, full duet (Netrebko/Alagna)
* Met 2011, climax (Netrebko/Beczala, clearer than complete video)
* Concert 2018, climax (Sierra/Fabiano, acted in front of orchestra)
* Paris 2020, full duet (Yende/Bernheim)
SOME OTHER SCENES
  Barcelona 2009   * Death duet (Dessay/Villazón)
  Met 2011   * Act IV trio (Netrebko/Beczala/Szot)
  Met 2019   * Trailer (very short)
* Act II aria, "Adieu, notre petite table" (Lisette Oropesa)
* Death duet (Oropesa/Fabiano)
  Paris 2020   * Act II aria, "En fermant les yeux" (Benjamin Bernheim)
* Death duet (Yende/Bernheim)
  Saint-Gallen 2014   * Trailer with director's explanation

• Return to top        • Return to index