3. Opera Structures. In adapting his novel La dame aux camélias (The Lady of the Camellias) for the stage in 1852, Alexandre Dumas fils had already done some of the work that Verdi's librettist Francesco Maria Piave would need to turn the piece into an opera, La traviata, the following year. A direct comparison between the spoken and sung versions affords a fascinating insight into Verdi's technique of constructing one of those dramatic scenes for two characters that are the life-blood of his operas. We shall also look more briefly at ways in which Verdi uses larger ensembles to create a dramatic climax.

PREPARING FOR THE CLASS. We shall be looking at two scenes from the opera in detail: the duet in the final scene between Alfredo and Violetta, and the Act II scene between Violetta and Alfredo's father, Germont. The attached EXCERPTS contain translations of the equivalent scenes in the opera, in the Dumas play, and in his earlier novel (the final scene does not occur in the novel). These are mainly for your reference, but I strongly advise reading the two passages as they appear in the play (pages 1–4 and 13–19) before class, as they will enable you to get much more out of what follows.

The script and video links will be posted immediately after class.
 

HANDOUTS

• EXERCISE: The Story of an Hour
• Excerpts from the novel, play, and libretto, in translation
• All charts shown in class

VIDEOS

The production of La traviata shown in class is not available on YouTube; instead, I give links to a 2006 production from San Francisco with Renée Fleming, Rolando Villazon, and Renato Bruson, which has English titles. Although we heard only one scene in each version, I have given links to both scenes in the film and radio productions of the Dumas play; neither of these, unfortunately, has titles.

  La dame aux camélias (film)   Marguerite and M. Duval
Marguerite and Armand (her death)
  Camille (US radio broadcast)   Camille and M. Duval
Camille and Armand (her death)
  La traviata (opera)   Violetta and Germont
Act II finale
Violetta and Alfredo (her death)

• Return to top        • Return to index