10. Manon's Rival Lovers The Abbé Antoine François Prévost (1697–1763) first published his Histoire du Chevalier des Grieux et Manon Lescaut (usually just called Manon Lescaut) in 1731. Due to its scandalous nature—it contains multiple sexual liasons and various kinds of criminal behavior—it was officially banned, but continued to circulate under the counter. Eventually, by toning some episodes down and giving it a more specific moral tone—warning against sin rather than wallowing in it—Prévost obtained sanctioned publication in 1753.

Not surprisingly, neither Jules Massenet (1884) nor Giacomo Puccini (1893) bothered with the moralizing in their operatic adaptations; their interest was entirely dramatic and emotional. Puccini famously said that "a woman like Manon could have more than one lover. Massenet feels it as a Frenchman, with powder and minuets. I shall feel it as an Italian, with a desperate passion." I think we shall see that both composers actually downplayed the minuets and both were equally passionate in their own language. But Massenet was arguably the more subtle in examining the psychology of his heroine. rb.

PREPARING FOR THE CLASS. Please make a point of reading my three-page synopsis of Prévost's novel. There is probably no need to read the book itself, as it is full of material that may only confuse the outline of the operatic plot. But for those who wish to check individual passages, there is a slightly old-fashioned but perfectly readable translation available free on Gutenberg.

The script, images, and video links will be posted immediately after the first class.
 

Neither of the main videos I played today is available on YouTube complete with English titles, but we don't do badly with substitutes. For the Massenet, we have the complete version we saw in class, though without titles, plus an older titled production with Renée Fleming that does have titles; I have also managed to find titled samples of each of the scenes we watched, though with other singers.

For the Puccini, we have the last 20 minutes of the production we watched, in three separate segments, with titles. For those wanting more, there is a 1997 complete production with titles from Glyndebourne, though it suffers from a bland Manon and shows its age. Much crisper is the 2017 production from Torino that we sampled briefly; although it has only Italian titles and also suffers from a physically less ideal Manon, it is the best period production out there.

*Asterisks indicate clips that are the same as those watched in class.
 

MASSENET
  Complete   * Berlin, 2008 (as played in class, no titles)
* Paris, 2001 (old video, with titles)
  Scenes   * "Adieu, notre petite table" (Callas in concert, with titles)
* Gavotte (Lisette Oropesa, with titles)
* Saint-Sulpice scene (Netebko/Beczala, with titles)
 
PUCCINI
  Complete   * Glyndebourne, 1997 (older production, with titles)
* Torino, 2017 (good video, traditional, no titles)
  Act II love scene   * Part 1 (Opolais/Kaufmann, with titles)
* Part 2
* Part 3

• Return to top        • Return to index