Two of the composers who created the genre of grand opéra in Paris in the 1830s were Jewish: Giacomo Meyerbeer and Fromenthal Halévy, whose opera La Juive (The Jewess, 1835) was to remain a cornerstone of the repertory for many decades. Though set in a real period of persecution in 15th-century Constance, it is highly romanticized, written for its spectacle and passion. We shall contrast this with clips from two post-Holocaust operas. The Passenger by Mieczyslaw Weinberg, composed in 1968 but not produced until 2010, is about a German woman traveling on a passenger liner whose accidental sight of a former camp inmate on a lower deck makes her relive her former life as a camp guard, which she has tried to hide even from her diplomat spouse. And The Promise by Mats Larsson Gothe, which premiered only this year, is a dreamlike (but real) account of a survivor's postwar journey to be reunited with her lost husband.

Brief synopses of the scenes we shall watch from all three operas are included in the handouts. Longer versions of each are given in the Synopses link above. For further information about The Passenger, I recommend this excellent article by David Pountney, who directed its stage premiere, and the intriguing trailer for his production. rb.
 

 
The two more recent operas (The Promise and The Passenger) are both available on YouTube complete. Many clips from the Antwerp production of La Juive are also available, though (as chance we have it) none of the scenes we watched in class. However, there are two other complete productions and several interesting clips. None of these has English titles—with the single exception of The Promise, which has inspired me to suggest a few other sections from that opera you might enjoy. *Asterisks indicate items not played in class.
 
I have also included links to articles articles on all three operas. The one on The Passenger particularly should answer some of the factual questions raised in class. rb.

GOTHE: THE PROMISE (2022)
  Complete opera   * Prologue (wedding scene)
* Aria, "Eternity sits on my shoulders" (Ava in Act I)
* Ava and Rosa (mother's cooking)
* Final scene (the reunion)
* Epilogue
  About the opera   * From the Royal Swedish Opera
 
WEINBERG: THE PASSENGER (1968)
  Premiere, Bregenz 2010   * Act I (complete act, no titles)
* Act II opening (complete act, no titles)
* Act II, Liese and Walter (the dance)
* Act II, final scene and epilogue
  English National Opera, 2011   * Trailer
  Chicago, 2015   * Trailer
  About the opera   * Wikipedia aricle
 
HALÉVY: LA JUIVE (1835)
  Complete productions   * Vienna 2003 (somewhat period setting; no titles)
* St. Petersburg (modern dress; no titles)
  Antwerp 2019   * Act I finale (different scenes from production shown in class)
* Act II finale
* Acts II and III, Princess Eudoxie (compilation)
* Act IV duet (Eléazar and Brogni)
* Eléazar's aria, "Rachel, quand du Seigneur" (Roy Cornelius Smith)
  Hamburg 2016   * Act III finale (unusual production by Calixto Bieto)
* Act V finale
  Eléazar aria (other clips)   * Neil Shicoff, Vienna 2003 (as shown in class)
* Jonas Kaufmann in concert
* Comparison of various tenors
  About the opera   * Wikipedia article

 
COMPOSERS

The class contains work by the following composers, given here in chronological order.
For bios of other composers in the course, click here.

Jacques Fromenthal Halévy (1799–1862). French composer.
 
The chorus master first at the Opéra Comique and then at the Paris Opera, Halévy achieved lasting fame with La Juive (The Jewess, 1835), one of the earliest and grandest of French grand operas, and dealing with an historical subject (persecution of the Jews in 1414) close to the composer's heart.
Mieczysław Weinberg (1919–96). Polish-Russian composer.
 
Weinberg escaped the Nazis by fleeing to Russia at the start of WW2. There he came under the influence of Dmitri Shostakovich, who encouraged his career. His prolific work, for a while largely forgotten, has benefitted from a revival of interest in the past decade, most notably including his post-Holocaust opera The Passenger (1968), which has been produced around the world following its 2010 premiere at the Bregenz Festival.
Mats Larsson Gothe (b.1965). Swedish composer.
 
Larsson Gothe has a long list of compositions in all genres, including both orchestral and chamber music. The Promise, which was commissioned by the Royal Swedish Opera for Holocaust Remembrance Day, January 2022, is his seventh opera.

• Return to index