WHAT IS A PORTRAIT?

In this first class, we will consider some of the many answers to this question. As a way of thinking about it in advance, however, consider these nine Degas pictures, not included in the class. All involve figures. A few are frankly portraits; a few others are clearly not; and a few more occupy an ambiguous area in the middle. Look through them first without titles and try to decide which is which.


1/9. CLICK IMAGE FOR NEXT


2/9


3/9


4/9


5/9


6/9


7/9


8/9


9/9


1/9. Place de la Concorde [Viscount Lepic with his daughters, but neither commissioned nor owned by him]


2/9. The Bellelli Family [the artist's aunt, young cousins, and uncle]


3/9. The Orchestra of the Opera [all the musicians can be identified]


4/9. At the Café-Concert; the Song of the Dog [the singer has been identified but is not credited]


5/9. Mary Cassatt Seated, Holding Cards


6/9. L'Absithe [Café de la Nouvelle-Athènes; models have been identified but are not credited]


7/9. The Millinery Shop


8/9. Woman Seated Beside a Vase of Flowers [conjecturally identified as the mother of #9]


9/9. Portrait of Mlle. Hortense Valpinçon

When you’re ready, click the link below to see each again with its title. [NOTE: text in square brackets is additional information, but not part of the official title.] If the exhibited title mentions the person’s name, does that automatically make the picture a portrait? What if we know who the person is, but they are not part of the title? What if there is more than one person in the picture? Can a depiction of someone in a casual setting also be a portrait? Must a portrait be in response to a formal commission (none of these examples are)? I'll offer some tentative answers to these questions here, but we will discuss such things in class. [SHOW TITLES] [SOME ANSWERS]

SOME PARTIAL ANSWERS: There are different categories, depending on the artist's relationship to the sitter or model:
Portraits commissioned by a third party for a fee would be unarguable, but nothing here is in that category.
The pictures of the Bellellis (2), Cassatt (5), and Mlle Valpinçon (9) at least declare themselves as portraits, though they are of friends and not done for money.
Place de la Concorde (1) and Woman with the Flowers (8) were also modeled by friends; the people are attractively presented in a meaningful context, but they are not the only subject of the picture.
Contemporaries (and historians) would no doubt recognize the musicians in the Orchestra (3) or Café (4); they are not personal portraits, but might serve as professional ones.
Finally, the Bar (6) and Millinery Shop (7) were clearly painted for their milieux; even when we can identify the model, as we can in L'Absinthe, she is clearly acting a role, not present in her own person, and thus not a portrait.