Handout (flat) Handout (folded) Synopsis (Met) Return to Index |
PROBLEM OPERAS SOLVED is the title of our course, and for the most part I will be addressing issues intrinsic to the
works themselves. But one topic has cropped up again and again in my research: the problem of adapting certain well-known
operas to the sensibilities of a Woke generation. So I thought it would be worthwhile to tackle the issue up front,
in today’s class and to a certain extent in the next. So, after a brief preview of the course as a whole, we shall
look at the problem of casting characters of color in opera and, equally importantly, giving performers of color the
opportunities they deserve. In the second hour, we turn to Puccini’s final opera, Turandot, whose vision of a
mythical China delights audiences but may also perpetuate ethnic and gender stereotypes. Because of its topic, this
is the only class in the course to feature multiple clips rather than a single opera.
In this and each of the classes that follow, I will include a link to the featured opera under Synopsis above, generally as a link to the Metropolitan Opera website; you may care to read it in advance. Given the topic of today's class, you might also like to read this 2016 article by Joshua Barone in the New York Times: Opera Can No Longer Ignore Its Race Problem. Other links and video excerpts will be posted immediately after class. rb.
Handout (flat) Handout (folded) Synopsis (Met) Class Script | Return to Index |
All the materials in the first hour of class were taken from YouTube videos, the links to which are given below. I also
include the full text of various articles I referred to, plus a couple of others that may be relevant. For the 2016 Aix
production of Così fan tutte, I include all four of the videos available on YouTube: an interview with the director,
Christophe Honoré, and two other scenes in addition to the one we watched. Unfortunately, the first of these is in French
and the others have titles in German only—but if you know the opera, you should find them very revealing.
Turandot, however, is more of a mixed bag. Both the Met and Helsinki productions are available complete, but one is so old as to drain it of all color, and the other has very little color to start with. The Royal Opera production, which we saw the most of, can be sampled only through a couple of trailers. I also include the television feature and the two articles on the productions in Toronto and Sydney. *Asterisks indicate items not seen in class.
INTRODUCTION | |||
Handel: Giulio Cesare | * Final duet (Danielle de Niese & Sarah Connolly, Glyndebourne) | ||
THE ELEPHANT IN THE ROOM | |||
Verdi: Otello |
* Otello's entrance: Domingo * Otello's entrance: Kaufmann * Otello's entrance: Thomas |
||
Verdi: Aïda | * Aïda/Amonasro duet (Leontyne Price, Simon Estes) | ||
Blanchard: Fire Shut Up in My Bones | * Trailer (Metropolitan Opera, 2022) | ||
Articles |
* NY Times on racism * WNO conference on blackface * Guardian on black/yellow-face * Seattle Times on Madama Butterfly |
||
NOT MERELY MAKEUP | |||
Mozart: Così fan tutte (Aix, 2016) |
* Director interview and Rehearsal
(Christophe Honoré, in French) * Fiordiligi/Dorabella duet (titles in German) * Dorabella/Guglielmo scene (titles in German) * Fiordiligi/Ferrando scene (titles in German) |
||
TURANDOT | |||
Metropolitan Opera (Zeffirelli) |
* Complete opera
(Met 1987; dark video, no titles) * — first Ping/Pang/Pong scene * — Act I finale * — Act III, Turandot and Liu * Opening of Act II, scene 2 (much higher quality) * Trailer (brief, but high quality) |
||
Royal Opera House (Serban) |
* Trailer * Magazine feature |
||
Finnish National Opera | * Complete opera (English titles) | ||
Toronto |
* Television news video * NYT letter from Katherine Hu |
||
Sydney | * Article by Cat-Thao Nguyen |