Mozart was just 22 when he received the commission to write an opera for the Elector of Bavaria, to be performed at the court theater in Munich. The commission, in a way, was an exercise in antiquarianism. The subject, Idomeneo, King of Crete, which was probably given to him, is a relatively obscure appendix to the Trojan War. The topic was not new, but had been set as an opera by at least one other composer 50 years earlier. And such a commission called for a grand style, based in the Handelian tradition of opera seria, but also taking account of the spectacles written more recently by Gluck.

Mozart wore such borrowed raiment well, but he was not to be constrained by it. In addition to its conventional elements, Idomeneo contains some of Mozart's richest orchestration, his most varied choruses, a number of ensembles not generally found in opera seria, and a texture that often reaches beyond accompanied recitative to sow the seeds for the continuous music drama of Wagner. For these reasons, Idomeneo is an opera that conductors want to tackle and singers want to sing. But for the stage director, the problem of its antique subject and formal manner remains. We shall look at three attempts to reconcile the old with the new.

This week's handout (links above) contains a synopsis of the opera. If you want to get a sample in advance, I would suggest one or more of the following: a simple telling of the story for a production in England, a trailer from a production in Berlin with a good selection from the music, and an introduction to the main production that we shall be watching by its director, Robert Carsen. Note, though, that the task of compiling a 2½-minute action trailer is very different from staging the piece at its full 2½-hour length.

 
As usual, a mixed bag. The original 1982 Met production by Jean-Pierre Ponnelle is available complete on YouTube with titles, though it is rather grainy and grey. A more recent revival from the Met is also available complete; it is much sharper but does not have titles. I also include a link to a complete production from La Scala, directed by Luc Bondy; it is by no means HD, but it does have titles.

For the other two productions (Dieter Dorn in Munich and Robert Carsen in both Madrid and Rome), we have to make do with trailers, interviews, and a scene from the Dorn that we did not get to see.* I also include links to reviews of each of these productions by a blog writer whose opinions I generally trust. The only other thing I include is the end of Act II in the "madhouse" production by Damiano Michieletto in Vienna, which I may or may not have had time for in class.

*The ending of the Dorn production merits a couple more notes:
1. Dorn ends the performance with the 12-minute ballet music that Mozart wrote for insertion in the opera elsewhere; you just see the beginning of this in the clip as the characters come back onstage, but in the performance the entire orchestra pit rises slowly to stage level, and it is the players rather than the singers who take the first bow.
2. It includes the scenery-chewing aria "D'Oreste, d'Ajace" for Electra, in which she drops her relatively lyric role as the "other woman" and reverts to type as the demonically possessed heroine of the Euripides play or the Strauss opera; I include a little gallery of various performances of this astounding aria. If you watch just one of these, make it Nicole Chevalier; you won't regret it! rb.

PONNELLE, NEW YORK 1982
  Original 1982 production   Complete (as played in class)
— Idomeneo aria "Fuor del mar"
— Chorus "Placido è il mar"
  2017 revival   Complete (sharper, but no titles)
 
BONDY, MILAN 2005
  Complete opera   Full opera (with rather obtrusive titles)
 
DORN, MUNICH 2008
  Various selections   Trailer
Sacrifice scene to the end (not played, but quite powerful)
  Review   From blog "Opera Ramblings" (John Gilks)
 
MICHIELETTO, VIENNA 2013
  End of Act II   Attack of the sea monster (Richard Croft)
 
CARSEN, ROME/MADRID 2019
  Trailers   Rome
Madrid
  Interviews   Rome (with conductor Michele Mariotti)
Madrid
  Review   From blog "Opera Ramblings" (John Gilks)
 
ELECTRA'S LAST ARIA
  "D'Oreste, d'Ajace"   Hildegard Behrens (Met 1982)
Emma Bell (Milan 2005)
Anja Harteros (Salzburg 2006)
Anna Netrebko (Salzburg 2006, in concert)
Annette Dasch (Munich 2008)
Nicole Chevalier (Salzburg 2019)
Hanna-Elisabeth Müller (Munich 2021)

• Return to index