Giuseppe Verdi was at the height of his powers when he wrote La forza del destino (The Force of Destiny) for Saint Petersburg in 1861, yet he kept tinkering with it for the rest of the decade. Why? He could never get the balance quite right, or shape the sprawling plot into a cohesive whole. A Spanish melodrama of the kind that had served him well enough for Il trovatore a decade earlier was no longer in tune with his new depth of psychological insight, yet his writing for the soprano heroine Leonora and the fierce duets between the two men who love her are some of the most powerful of his career. Thanks to video, we are in the fortunate position of being able to compare a revival from Saint Petersburg in the original sets to a modern approach such as the 2016 Munich production by Martin Kusej that will occupy the larger portion of the class.

The class handout (links above) includes an outline of the story insofar as the major characters are concerned; for a longer synopsis that also includes the minor ones, click here. In this particular case, the eight-minute overture that Verdi wrote for later performances gives an excellent feel for the melodies and many dramatic moods of the opera that follows. rb.

 
The production from St. Petersburg that we sampled in class is available on YouTube complete, and in good quality; it is a pity it is not a more engaging interpretation, but it is the best available with English titles. The Munich production is also available complete (for now) in a German television broadcast including interesting intermission features, but these are in German, and there are no titles. I do, however, have three good clips from this production, one of which does have titles, and also a review in English which will give you a far better account of it than I could. I would also draw your attention to the trailers of three other modern productions that I threw in at the end; no matter what language they are in, the combination of music and stage action in each is gripping; I have listed them in order of increasing radicality. rb.

PRODUCTIONS SEEN IN CLASS
  St. Petersburg 1998   Acts 1 and 2 (complete, with titles)
Acts 3 and 4 (complete, with titles)
  Munich 2016   Complete (German tv broadcast, no titles)
Trailer
Act 1 love duet (Anja Harteros, Jonas Kaufmann)
Act 4 Carlo/Alvaro duet (Ludovic Tézier, Jonas Kaufmann, w/titles)
Act 4 aria, "Pace, pace, mio Dio" (Anja Harteros)
Operawire review (well worth reading!)
 
OTHER PRODUCTIONS
  Christof Loy, Amsterdam   Trailer
Excerpt, "La vergine degl'Angeli" (Eva-Maria Westbroek)
  Andreas Homoki, Zurich   Trailer
English-language news clip
  Tobias Kratzer, Frankfurt   Trailer with interviews

• Return to index