5. La Bohème. When Giacomo Puccini (1858–1924) adapted Scènes de la vie de bohème by Henri Murger as an opera in 1896, his version received only modest acclaim; his rival Ruggiero Leoncavallo did better with his adaptation the following year. Posterity has totally reversed that evaluation. Puccini's opera is essentially an intimate story involving a handful of people, all young and struggling to make a place for themselves. Ever since Franco Zeffirelli directed the opera at La Scala in 1963 (a production remounted at the Met in 1982), his style of romantic ultra-realism has shaped the expectations of generations of opera-goers. We shall contrast scenes from that production with those from a much more recent one from Berlin by the Australian director Barrie Kosky, who throws out Zeffirelli-type spectacle in favor of a closer focus on the characters and their feelings. At stake is the question of what is more important in opera, production or people? rb.

 
The script, videos, and images will be posted immediately after class.

 
The iconic Zeffirelli production is available complete on YouTube with English subtitles in a film based on its first incarnation at La Scala. This is very similar to the one that came to the Met; I include two scenes from that version also, including the stupendous ending to Act Two. I also give a link to a basically traditional 1986 production by Giancarlo Menotti from Genoa, starring Luciano Pavarotti, also with English titles. For samples of all the other directors shown in class, I have to rely on trailers and clips—though I especially recommend the introduction to the opera by Barrie Kosky and colleagues, which is as much about the piece as his production of it. rb.

COMPLETE WITH ENGLISH TITLES
  Franco Zeffirelli   Film, 1965 (based on La Scala 1963 production)
  Giancarlo Menotti   Acts 1 and 2 (Pavarotti, Genoa 1986)
Acts 3 and 4 (as above)
 
TRAILERS AND CLIPS
  Claus Guth   Trailer (Paris 2017)
Mimì's Act III aria (as above, with Sonya Yoncheva)
  Stefan Herheim   Trailer (Oslo 2012)
  Barrie Kosky   Trailer (Komische Oper, Berlin 2019)
Act IV opening (as above)
About the opera and production (excellent 25-minute documentary)
  Damiano Michieletto   Trailer (Salzburg 2012)
Act IV duet (extended excerpt, German titles)
  Jonathan Miller   Act I complete (Paris 2009)
  Franco Zeffirelli   Act II finale (Metropolitan Opera 2014)
Act III quartet (Metropolitan Opera 1998)

• Return to top        • Return to index